I wrote an article about cheating, and a few readers disagreed with whether emotional cheating exists. One went so far as to argue that best friends could be considered as cheating with each other because they have a close bond.
I was flabbergasted by those responses because emotional affairs are so CLEARLY different than friendships to me.
For example, I’ve never emotionally cheated with my best friend. I talk about sex really frankly with her, but I don’t sext with her. I tell her she’s hot, but I’m saying that not because I secretly want to take her panties off, but because she was feeling insecure and needed some validation. I’ve told her things I’d never want to tell my partner, but those things were like how hard it was to poop last week or how my period was weird, NOT things I should talk to my partner about like, “I’m really frustrated that he has seemed so self-centered lately, and I have a lot going on right now too and I need his support.” And if I DID tell my best friend something like that, my next step definitely should be to share that with my partner.
Close intimate friendships with the opposite or same sex are VASTLY different than emotional affairs. I can understand how abusive partners can make it seem like it’s not okay for their partner to have any friendships. Isolating a spouse from friendships is one of the warning signs of emotional abuse. A spouse does not have exclusive 100% rights over a partner’s friendships, interests, and sense of space and privacy. I am, in fact, NOT saying that.
What I am instead saying is that emotional affairs exist, do happen, and are a thing to be cognizant of if you want to remain faithful. They are especially likely to happen if your relationship is in trouble or if you have trouble setting and keeping boundaries.
What I also want to add is
If you have to ask yourself the question, “am I having an emotional affair?,” you probably are.
That’s because, if you were truly being honest with yourself, you wouldn’t even question if what you were doing was okay. You would just know it.
I’ve never asked myself if I was having an emotional affair with my best friend because that is so ridiculous that it‘s fucking hysterical. I would laugh in your face if you asked me that.
BUT I have had a few past relationships where if you asked me that, I’d probably pause before answering or get super defensive. Because I’d know — and have felt — that there wasn’t something quite above board about those relationships.
Here are some questions to help you tease out if your friendship is actually on its way to being or is currently an emotional affair:
- Are you keeping anything about your relationship a secret from your current partner?
- Are you spending less and less time talking, spending time with, or being intimate with your partner to spend with this other person instead?
- Is there a degree or element of sexual attraction that is or isn’t acknowledged by either party?
- Are you sharing things (thoughts, feelings, or problems) with your friend that would best be addressed with your partner instead? (see examples above.)
Having had a few almost and total emotional affairs, I can say unequivocally that emotional affairs are real. They are insidious and can sneak up on you at any time if you aren’t practicing clear boundaries.
I used them as a way to avoid what I really needed to be looking at: how wrong my current relationship was and how I needed to leave. They helped keep me stuck. One emotional affair turned into a full-blown affair that became the crowbar I used to leave my marriage.
So, if you pause or immediately get defensive when you think about whether one or some of your relationships are actually emotional affairs: take note, my friend, because you are probably in one.
When I was 19, I got engaged to a 28-year-old man with a 3-year-old daughter. I was attending college in another state, and he lived in my hometown, so for the first year of us dating, we commuted back and forth. Then I left college to move in with him.
It was a relationship sustained on liberal fantasy. I knew this dude was not for me: I felt constantly like I was compromising my morals and values to be with him, and I didn’t want to be a step-parent when I felt like barely an adult myself.
So I started complaining about him and our relationship to one of my male friends. We started flirting a little. I started texting him all the time and then telling my partner that I was actually texting my friend Mary. I started yearning to talk to him more and more. I told him things like, “I wish Scott would get me the way you do!”
When my partner finally saw whom I was texting with, he confronted me. “We’re just friends!” I told him. But I knew. I knew that it wasn’t true. I knew that if this was truly a platonic friendship, then I wouldn’t be lying about it. I wouldn’t be keeping a secret. If I was truly doing nothing wrong, then I wouldn’t be concerned if my partner happened to see what we were texting. Instead, I broke out in a cold sweat thinking about how my partner would react to comments I’d made to this “friend” like, “You look great with your shirt off! (winky face emoji)”
In M.Gary Neuman’s book, Emotional Infidelity: How to Affair-Proof Your Marriage and 10 Other Secrets to a Great Relationship, he makes the controversial statement: “Insulate and protect your marriage against emotional infidelity by avoiding friendships with members of the opposite sex.” Neuman believes that limiting your relationships/friendships is “the single most important thing you can do for your marriage.”
That’s preposterous. You CAN have relationships with people of the opposite sex (or same sex if you’re in a same-sex relationship) that are entirely platonic and healthy and GOOD for you and your relationship, but boundaries MUST be in place.
Here are boundaries to consider having:
- If unmet needs, irritations, or problems with your partner arise, don’t let them remain uncommunicated or unaddressed for too long.
- If you take problems about your partner or your relationship to another person, make SURE to then bring those issues back to your partner.
- If you find yourself connecting with or reaching out more to a friend than your partner, schedule some quality time with your partner.
- If you find yourself feeling attracted to a friend, limit the time you engage with that person.
- If you feel the need to hide something or keep it a secret, tell on yourself to your partner. Nothing hurts trust more than deception.
One reader commented, “emotional affairs…act as a canary in the mine for unhappy relationships,” which I find to be so so so true. When I have desired something from my partner that I wasn’t getting, sometimes the first sign of it to me was when I found myself seeking those things from other people. If I want to remain in my committed relationship, my next step should be in returning to my partner.